The UK’s open banking era may have commenced on 13 January but it did so in an underwhelming fashion.
The launch has been marred by a failure of many banks to meet the deadline, public suspicion, and sceptical media coverage.
Timeline for Comment wire
- July 10, 2020
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) had mandated the UK’s nine largest banking providers to make their systems compliant with the new legislation by the launch date.
However, six of these – including Barclays, HSBC, Nationwide, and RBS – failed to meet the deadline and have been given up to six more weeks to comply.
Nevertheless, the delay should only prove a temporary snag – all banks should have their APIs activated by the start of March, assuming no further slippage.
A bigger challenge is posed by consumer wariness, fomented by mainstream media coverage that has focused as much on the perceived security risks of open banking as on the benefits.
A piece in the Guardian, which alongside a summary of the changes and a description of the positive impact upon consumer outcomes, discussed the risks of using unproven third parties.
Even the Sun followed suit with its story: FRAUD ALERT What is Open Banking? When does it start? Are your details at risk from fraud?
In addition, up until a few weeks before the launch date, the media had barely discussed open banking at all.
Consequently, people have been left in the dark, with a survey conducted in August–September 2017 by Which revealing that 92 percent of people had never heard of open banking.
Although recent press coverage will have reduced this percentage since then, first impressions count, and a high proportion of consumers are likely to be put off by the negative slant of much of the initial coverage.
Confirming this, research by Accenture has found that 69 percent of consumers would not want to share their data with third parties, and 53 percent intend to avoid open banking altogether.
The State of Technology This Week
Open banking legislation, which was conceived in order to increase competition and reduce the dominance of the biggest banks, may therefore fall short of its objectives.
If fintech firms and other challengers were hoping that open banking would be a magic bullet that would help them to quickly and significantly scale up, they will almost certainly be disappointed.
For obvious reasons, the main banks do not want to publicise the benefits of open banking, so it is up to the CMA, which ordered the change in the first place, to embark upon a comprehensive publicity campaign to educate the public.